
When a company receives several offers, the natural instinct is to rank them by price. The headline number is the easiest to compare and the one buyers lead with, but it is rarely the amount a seller receives. Earn-outs, deferred payments, rollover equity, escrows and adjustments at completion all sit between the headline and the cash that reaches shareholders, and together they can move the real value of an offer by millions of dollars.
In our experience, the offer with the highest headline is often not the strongest. Understanding how each element works, and what it is worth in practice, is the starting point for comparing offers properly and negotiating the terms that matter most.
In our video on the sale process, we compare three final offers for the same business. Expressed in dollars, for a company where the highest offer is $50 million, they look like this:
| Bidder | Headline price | Cash at completion | Deferred payments and earn-out | Rollover equity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | $50.0M | $31.0M | $19.0M | None |
| B | $47.0M | $43.0M | $4.0M | None |
| C | $46.0M | $36.0M | None | $10.0M |
Bidder A leads on price by $3 million. At completion, however, it pays $12 million less than Bidder B, and the remaining $19 million depends on payments due over the following years and on the business meeting targets the buyer has set. Bidder C pays $36 million at completion and asks shareholders to keep $10 million invested alongside it, which brings risk as well as the chance of a second payout. Bidder B offers the most cash at completion and the most certainty of closing, and in this example it was the offer we recommended.
An earn-out pays part of the price only if the business reaches agreed targets after completion, usually revenue or EBITDA over one to three years. Buyers use them to bridge the gap between what the seller believes the business is worth and what the buyer is prepared to pay today. They appeared in around a quarter of private company sales last year, and the potential earn-out in a typical deal was equal to about a third of the price paid at closing.
The amount actually paid is usually far lower. Sellers receive something in just over half of deals with an earn-out, but across all of them buyers have ultimately paid only around 21% of the maximum available. Part of the reason is that the seller no longer runs the business, and once the buyer controls pricing, hiring, integration and accounting, it controls many of the levers that decide whether a target is met.
An earn-out can still be the right answer, particularly where the business is growing quickly and the seller has good reason to believe in the forecast. The protections then matter as much as the amount: targets defined in plain accounting terms, clear rules on how the business will be run during the earn-out period, payments for partial achievement, and acceleration if the business is sold again.
Deferred consideration is part of the price paid after completion, on fixed dates and in fixed amounts. Because it does not depend on future performance, it is usually worth more than an earn-out of the same size, but it still carries risk. The seller is waiting for money from a buyer it no longer controls, and the payment is only as reliable as the buyer's ability to pay when it falls due.
A seller note works in a similar way. The seller lends part of the purchase price to the buyer and is repaid over several years with interest, usually behind the banks or private credit lenders financing the deal, who are paid first if the business struggles after completion.
The questions to ask are who stands behind the payment, whether it is guaranteed or secured, where it ranks against other debt and whether the buyer can set it off against claims under the purchase agreement. A deferred payment from a well-capitalized strategic acquirer can be close to cash. The same amount owed by a buyer carrying heavy debt deserves a meaningful discount.
Private equity buyers often ask sellers to reinvest part of their proceeds in the new ownership structure, and rollover has featured in more than half of deals valued between $25 million and $500 million in recent years. For the buyer, it keeps the seller committed and reduces the cash needed at completion. For the seller, it offers a second payout when the sponsor sells the business again, typically five years or more later, and the rolled portion can often be structured so that tax on it is deferred.
The value of that stake depends on terms that are easy to overlook. Sellers should understand whether they hold the same class of shares as the sponsor, whether preferred returns or fees sit ahead of them, how much debt the new structure carries and what rights they have when the sponsor decides to sell.
On good terms, rollover equity can turn out to be the most valuable part of an offer. On poor terms, it is a minority stake in a heavily indebted company that the seller can neither sell nor control.
Most purchase agreements hold back part of the price after completion to cover claims if something in the seller's representations turns out to be wrong. Without insurance, the median indemnity escrow in private deals is around 10% of the price, usually held for a year or more. On a $47 million offer, that is $4.7 million the seller will not receive until the claims period ends, and may not receive in full.
Representations and warranties insurance has changed this. It was used in close to half of private deals last year, and where it was in place the median indemnity escrow fell to around 0.5% of the price, because the insurer covers most claims that the seller would otherwise bear. Two offers with the same headline can therefore leave very different amounts tied up after completion, depending on whether the buyer is prepared to rely on a policy and how its cost is shared.
Most offers are made on a cash-free, debt-free basis, assuming a normal level of working capital in the business. At completion, the price is adjusted for the cash and debt actually there, and for any difference between the working capital delivered and an agreed target, often called the peg. Adjustments of this kind appear in more than 90% of private deals.
The peg is usually based on an average of recent months, and where it is set can move the price significantly. A business with seasonal swings, a large order book or unusual payment terms can find that a peg set at the wrong level transfers value to the buyer without the headline price changing at all. The definitions matter too, since every item counted as debt, from deferred revenue to unpaid bonuses and tax liabilities, reduces what the seller receives.
The final adjustment averages less than 1% of the price, but it goes the buyer's way in about half of deals and the seller's in fewer than four in ten, and close to three in ten deals see the buyer's first calculation disputed. The time to settle these questions is while negotiating the letter of intent, before exclusivity weakens the seller's negotiating position.
When final offers arrive, we put each one on the same basis before making a recommendation. We separate cash at completion from everything that depends on time, performance or the buyer's balance sheet, then value each part realistically: deferred payments discounted for timing and credit risk, earn-outs for the likelihood of achievement, rollover on its terms and escrows on what is likely to come back.
Certainty of closing carries as much weight as value. A buyer's financing, its approvals, the diligence it still needs and its record of completing deals all bear on whether the price on paper becomes money in the bank. An offer that is slightly lower but fully financed, with diligence nearly complete, is often worth more than a higher one that still depends on a financing condition.
The comparison also shapes the next round of negotiation. Once the gaps between offers are clear, we can focus on the terms that move value most, whether that is more cash at completion, a shorter earn-out with simpler targets or a smaller escrow backed by insurance.
The headline price is where a negotiation starts. Sellers who understand how each part of an offer is valued, and which terms carry the most risk, are in a far stronger position to choose the right buyer and to improve the terms they are offered.
That work is best done before offers arrive. It means deciding in advance what matters most, whether that is cash at completion, a continuing role in the business or a stake in its future, and running a process competitive enough that buyers improve their terms as well as their price.
